The risk that an untrained bystander can do harm by giving cardiopulmonary resuscitation, or CPR, to someone who collapses in public is almost vanishingly small, a new study indicates.
And so the dispatchers who send emergency medical help when 911 is called should routinely tell the caller to start CPR, said Thomas D. Rea, MD, an associate professor of medicine at the University of Washington, and lead author of a report in an online issue of Circulation.
"There have been concerns expressed by laypeople and dispatchers that doing CPR might cause damage," Dr. Rea said. "Our study shows that you can help the person at risk and the chances that you can injure someone who is not in cardiac arrest are very, very small, and those injuries are not serious."
The Study
Dr. Rea and his colleagues used data on 1,700 adults who received CPR in the King County emergency response system in a 36-month period. Dr. Rea is program medical director of the King County program. Of those, 55% were in cardiac arrest and 45% were not. Nearly half of those not in cardiac arrest received CPR from bystanders.
The data showed minor problems-discomfort or injuries in 9% to 11% of cases-but only four fractures, three due to chest compressions administered during CPR, one from repositioning the individual for CPR.
And while this study did not measure the benefits of giving CPR even when it eventually turned out to be unnecessary, "many studies have shown that the odds of surviving cardiac arrest increase by 20, 30, 100 percent, depending on what study you look at, when CPR is given," Dr. Rea said.
Implication
“The key finding here is that when a well-meaning member of the general public starts CPR and the victim is not in cardiac arrest, it will probably cause no injury at all," said Michael Sayre, MD, an associate professor of emergency medicine at Ohio State University, and a spokesperson for the American Heart Association. "The study reassures me that rescuers are rarely going to do any kind of injury."
When To Give CPR
King County emergency dispatchers use a basic two-question format to determine whether CPR should be started. They ask if the person conscious and if the person is breathing normally.
"If the answers are 'no, the dispatcher tells the caller to get the victim on a hard surface, on his back, bare the chest, put the hands in the center of the chest right between the nipples and then start compressions of one to two inches, counting aloud," Dr. Rea said. The dispatcher counts along with the CPR giver, and the routine continues until the emergency response team arrives.
It can end sooner if the person getting CPR regains consciousness and tells the rescuer to stop.
There often is uncertainty at the caller's end of the telephone encounter, Dr. Sayre said. "I know there can be hesitation in terms of training and doing it in person. But this shows that evaluating the situation quickly and starting CPR will rarely do any harm."
