Two commonly used blood pressure medications seem to have opposite effects on the chances of breast cancer recurring in women with a personal history of the disease.

Preliminary findings show that ACE inhibitors, a class of drugs used to treat heart problems, were associated with an increased risk of recurrence, which surprised even the researchers, who published their study online in the journal Breast Cancer Research and Treatment.

On the other hand, beta-blockers, a different class of heart medications, were associated with a reduced risk, which is in keeping with prior studies on the subject.

When the two drugs were combined, beta-blockers seemed to mitigate the increased risk of recurrence linked with ACE inhibitors.

The study suggested that certain medications used to treat heart disease and high blood pressure might have an adverse effect on breast cancer survivors, said study first author Patricia A. Ganz, MD, director of cancer prevention and control research at the Jonsson Comprehensive Cancer Center at University of California, Los Angeles.


A 2010 study by Jonsson Comprehensive Cancer Center researchers on mice had already looked at beta-blockers and cancer spread or metastasis). That study began by documenting that stress can affect how fast and how widely a tumor spreads in rodents. The mice were confined in a small tube for a couple of hours a day, and the resulting stress prompted immune cells to gather in the tumor cells, enabling quicker metastasis and a 30-fold increase in cancer spread, deeper analysis revealed.

But in this animal model, beta-blockers managed to block the signals that were recruiting the immune cells, explained Dr. Ganz.

That same year, a study of more than 400 women in England and Germany found that women on beta-blockers also had a lower likelihood of breast cancer recurrence.

New Study

The UCLA researchers decided to delve deeper, working with other scientists on a database of 1,779 women with early-stage breast cancer who had been treated at a large health maintenance organization in northern California and followed for about eight years in a study called Life After Cancer Epidemiology (LACE).

The women in the group who were taking ACE inhibitors had a 56% increased risk of a recurrence, although they had no increased risk of death.

The 14% of women who were taking propanolol—the beta-blocker considered most likely to have a protective effect-had a reduced risk of recurrence. Because the number of women in this group was so small, the findings did not reach statistical significance, Dr. Ganz said, although it was going in the right direction in terms of being protective."

The risk associated with taking both drugs together was somewhat in the middle.

The study was funded by the Jonsson Comprehensive Cancer Center Foundation, the Breast Cancer Research Foundation and the US National Cancer Institute.

Noting the need for further studies, Dr. Ganz is working with researchers in Denmark and Canada to evaluate the same medications and their relationship to recurrence in much larger samples of breast cancer patients.

Expert Commentary

"We've always been addressing the treatment of the cancer itself but in this study (they were looking at whether there is something in the host, in the milieu that makes us more susceptible to the development of a malignancy. Is there something we can actually change?" said Lauren Cassell, MD, chief of breast surgery at Lenox Hill Hospital in New York City.

"People have to realize this is just a work-in-progress and shouldn't stop their medicines if they happen to be on one of these medications," said Nieca Goldberg, MD, director of the Women's Heart Program at NYU Langone Medical Center in New York City.

"If they are concerned because they have breast cancer or they're at high risk for breast cancer," Dr. Goldberg said, "they should really express this to their doctors because there are other options for medicines."

Want to Keep Reading?

Continue reading with a Health Confidential membership.

Sign up now Already have an account? Sign in